View all AI news articles

The AI Experiment Gone Awry at CNET

May 17, 2024

Summary Outline

  • Background: Exploring the incident where CNET used AI to write articles, leading to controversy and impact on its sale.
  • AI Integration: Discussion on CNET's integration of AI in article writing, leading to errors and lack of transparency.
  • Repercussions: Examining the consequences for CNET, including staff unionizing and the sale struggles of its parent company, Red Ventures.
  • The Future of AI in Journalism: Reflecting on the broader implications of AI in journalism and its potential ethical concerns.

Background: When AI Pen Meets Paper

Once upon a time in the vast landscape of tech journalism, CNET decided to let AI dip its virtual toes in article writing. This wasn't your average, run-of-the-mill experiment, though. Imagine a tech site, revered for its human touch, suddenly playing host to a digital scribe, churning out articles under the guise of "CNET Money Staff". This move, while innovative, had a bit of a hiccup – the articles were riddled with errors and accusations of plagiarism surfaced. To make matters more interesting, CNET's parent company Red Ventures found itself in a pickle trying to sell this storied website, thanks in part to the AI scandal. The tech site’s journey from a respected source to a potential cautionary AI tale is something worth chewing on​​.

AI Integration: More Than Meets the Eye

Back in November 2022, CNET unleashed its AI, producing 73 financial explainer posts. The catch? The byline "CNET Money Staff" was a digital masquerade for AI-generated content. Only by clicking the byline would readers discover the AI's role – talk about a hidden Easter egg! This lack of clarity didn't sit well with the audience or the journalistic community. While using AI isn’t a novel concept in journalism – the Associated Press and Washington Post have dabbled in it for routine tasks – CNET’s approach lacked the transparency that’s critical when introducing such technologies. The outcome? CNET took down the AI’s bio page and removed the "Staff" from its posts​​.

Repercussions: Unionizing and Sale Struggles

CNET's AI adventure led to more than just a few raised eyebrows. The CNET Media Workers Union formed, waving the flag for job protections, editorial independence, and a voice in AI-related decisions. This unionization was a direct response to the uncertainty and job threats posed by AI. Meanwhile, Red Ventures, the overlord of CNET, faced the music in the market. Trying to sell CNET turned into a Herculean task, with potential buyers side-eyeing the brand following the AI fiasco. The website, once valued near $2 billion, now struggles to regain its former glory​​.

The Future of AI in Journalism: A Balancing Act

The CNET saga serves as a looking glass into the future of AI in journalism. The key takeaway? Brand reputation is a delicate flower in the garden of media. CNET’s journey from a tech reporting titan to an example of AI misuse underscores the need for transparency and ethical considerations in AI deployment. While AI holds the promise of transforming journalism, it's a path that requires careful treading, ensuring that the trust between readers and publications remains unshaken​​.

Recent articles

View all articles